Measuring the ROI of AI in ITSM: Key Strategies to Demonstrate Value and Efficiency

IT service management (ITSM) is entering a pivotal stage driven by the rapid advancement of Artificial Intelligence (AI). More and more organizations are adopting these technologies to automate processes, optimize costs, enhance user experience, and anticipate business needs with more proactive services. However, the promise of AI comes with a critical question: how can organizations ensure that these investments truly generate value?

For leaders in Latin America, this question carries even greater strategic weight. The region is experiencing fast-paced technological adoption, yet it also faces budget constraints and a constant need to demonstrate the real impact of every digital initiative.

This guide outlines the most effective methods for evaluating the return on investment (ROI) of AI projects in ITSM, the key metrics to consider, and the benchmarks that help validate whether your strategy is delivering tangible benefits aligned with your organization’s goals.

‍

Why Measuring AI ROI in IT Service Management Matters

AI-enabled ITSM automates and enhances critical processes such as incident management, request fulfillment, change management, and problem resolution. While the advantages of incorporating AI are numerous, including cost savings and improved service quality, not every implementation is guaranteed to yield positive returns.

Stakeholder Buy-In: Illustrating AI ROI supports funding for future initiatives and continual improvement.

Risk Mitigation: Defining clear ITSM investment metrics prior to rollout helps ensure investments don’t outstrip benefits.

Stakeholder Buy-In: Illustrating AI ROI supports funding for future initiatives and continual improvement.

Alignment with Business Outcomes: Connecting ITSM improvements to broader organizational goals maximizes impact and relevance.

Continuous Improvement: ROI measurements uncover areas needing refinement, helping your ITSM evolve intelligently.

By establishing robust mechanisms for AI project evaluation, organizations avoid expensive missteps and maximize the return on every peso, real, or dollar invested.

‍

Key Metrics to Evaluate AI Investments in ITSM

For AI-powered ITSM initiatives, relying on traditional IT metrics alone is insufficient. Instead, organizations should adopt a hybrid approach, blending operational, financial, and user-impact metrics aligned with AI’s unique capabilities.

1. Cost Savings and Efficiency Gains

Reduction in Manual Work: Measure the percentage decrease in labor hours dedicated to repetitive tasks such as ticket triage, password resets, and routine maintenance after AI implementation.

Service Desk Cost per Ticket: Calculate changes in the average cost to resolve tickets, factoring in the automation enabled by AI-driven chatbots and virtual agents.

Ticket Backlog Reduction: Assess whether AI helps decrease the volume of unresolved tickets over time, allowing staff to focus on higher-value tasks.

2. Service Quality and Response Time

First Contact Resolution (FCR) Rate: Track the percentage of tickets resolved during the initial interaction, a key indicator of AI’s ability to provide accurate, real-time solutions.

Average Response and Resolution Times: Compare pre- and post-AI implementation times for ticket acknowledgment and closure.

Error Rate: Monitor any reduction in human error by tracking service delivery mistakes before and after AI deployment.

3. User Experience and Satisfaction

User Satisfaction (CSAT) Scores: Gather feedback from both end-users and IT staff to measure perceptions of speed, efficiency, and quality after AI adoption.

Net Promoter Score (NPS): Assess whether users are more likely to recommend IT services due to AI-driven improvements.

Self-Service Adoption Rate: Evaluate the increase in users leveraging AI-enabled self-service portals and chatbots for routine requests.

4. Operational and Business Impact

AI Project Payback Period: Determine how long it takes for the cost savings and efficiency gains to cover the initial investment in AI-driven solutions.

Process Automation ROI: Quantify the total return based on the cost-to-benefit equation for each automated workflow.

Change Success Rate: Measure the reduction in failed changes and incidents caused by poor change management, often improved with AI-driven analytics and recommendations.

Building a Framework for AI Project Evaluation

It’s not enough to select metrics randomly, organizations should build a rigorous, repeatable framework for evaluating every AI investment in ITSM. This ensures consistency, accountability, and transparency in how success is measured and communicated to stakeholders.

Step 1: Align AI Projects with Business Objectives

Begin by connecting each AI initiative to specific business outcomes, such as lowering operational costs, accelerating service delivery, or improving compliance.

Collaborate with business units to ensure ITSM investment metrics reflect both IT and organizational priorities (e.g., customer retention, risk mitigation, or regulatory adherence).

Step 2: Define Baselines and Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

Identify current-state baselines for all core metrics (pre-AI project conditions).

Set clear, quantifiable KPIs for each AI objective, such as a 30% reduction in ticket resolution times within the first quarter of deployment.

Step 3: Calculate Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)

Account for both direct (software, hardware, integration, training) and indirect (change management, employee upskilling, ongoing support) costs.

Include expected operational savings and efficiency gains over the life of the solution.

Step 4: Monitor and Report Outcomes Regularly

Institute dashboards or automated reporting for continuous tracking of your ITSM investment metrics.

Share progress with key stakeholders, highlighting successes and areas requiring adjustment.

Iterate on AI configurations and workflows to optimize ROI over time.

Step 5: Review and Refine

Evaluate both short-term (months) and long-term (year over year) results.

Refine KPIs, targets, or project scope as your ITSM and business needs mature.

‍

Industry Benchmarks: What Does AI ROI Look Like in ITSM?

To ensure you aren’t navigating in the dark, it’s critical to compare your performance against industry benchmarks. While results vary based on organization size, maturity, and the specific solutions deployed, leading research points to significant gains for well-managed AI projects.

Cost Reductions: According to IDC and Gartner, organizations adopting AI in ITSM often report service desk cost decreases of 25-40% within the first 18-24 months.

Faster Service: Companies utilizing virtual agents or AI-powered automation frequently see ticket resolution times improve by 30-50%.

Increased Self-Service Adoption: Sophisticated AI-driven portals can raise self-service usage rates from under 20% to over 60%, easing pressure on IT teams.

Higher Satisfaction Scores: Early adopters in financial services and telecommunications in Latin America noted CSAT improvement by as much as 20 points after AI chatbot and workflow projects.

These benchmarks serve as a useful guide when goal-setting and creating expectations with your stakeholders. However, it’s important to adjust targets for your organization’s unique context, structure, and technology maturity.

‍

Challenges and Pitfalls to Avoid in Measuring AI ROI

While the foundation for assessing AI ROI in ITSM is clear, several pitfalls can undermine your results, especially in rapidly evolving environments common to Latin America and the Caribbean.

Overlooking Hidden Costs: Factors such as change management, technical debt, and vendor lock-in can erode your actual ROI if not carefully considered.

Relying on Vanity Metrics: Don’t let superficial metrics (like number of tickets automated) overshadow genuine business value such as user satisfaction, error reduction, or retention improvements.

Underestimating Data Quality Issues: Poor data hygiene limits AI’s effectiveness. Invest in cleansing and structuring your ITSM data up front for better outcomes and measurement accuracy.

Failing to Revisit Metrics: AI’s value compounds over time, so routine measurement and adjustment are essential, especially as your processes and user base grow.

‍

Tailoring AI ROI Measurement for Latin America and the Caribbean

Organizations in Latin America and the Caribbean are uniquely positioned to leapfrog legacy IT practices through strategic AI adoption in ITSM. Yet, the region also faces specific challenges, such as limited budgets, less mature data infrastructure, and talent shortages.

Leverage Localized Benchmarks

Prioritize regional and industry-specific case studies when setting performance targets, what works in North America or Europe may not fully apply locally due to regulatory, cultural, or operational differences.

Join local ITSM or AI peer groups to share practical ROI stories and learnings.

Adapt Metrics to Regional Realities

Factor in local labor costs, infrastructure constraints, and user adoption challenges when projecting ROI.

Choose metrics that resonate with local business drivers, for example, regulatory compliance, digital accessibility, or support for mobile-first users.

Invest in Change Management and Training

Align AI investments with workforce upskilling, ensuring your IT team can manage new solutions and support continuous improvement.

Foster a culture of innovation by demonstrating clear, early wins, leveraging smaller pilot projects as proof points for larger AI-driven transformations.

‍

Best Practices: Maximizing the ROI of AI in ITSM

To truly unlock the value of AI in ITSM, organizations should follow several proven best practices:

Prioritize High-Impact Use Cases: Start with automation and AI deployments where the potential for cost savings, productivity gains, or user impact is greatest (e.g., automated ticket routing, intelligent knowledge base search).

Build Cross-Functional Teams: Involve IT, business units, and data specialists throughout AI project lifecycles to bridge gaps between technology and organizational outcomes.

Iterate and Scale: Launch pilot programs, measure results, and refine, then gradually scale successful solutions across the enterprise.

Measure Far Beyond Cost: Track metrics like user sentiment, agility, scalability, and resilience improvements, not just hard-dollar savings.

Leverage Advanced Analytics: Use AI and analytics not only to optimize ITSM, but also to drive predictive insights and continuous feedback for ROI improvements.

‍

Ensuring Your AI Investments Deliver Lasting Value

Measuring the ROI of AI in IT service management is a practice that blends rigorous analysis with strategic vision. It requires aligning every initiative with business objectives, defining clear metrics, evaluating results continuously, and adjusting course based on real performance. For organizations in Latin America, this process is not only essential, it is also an opportunity to accelerate digital transformation, strengthen competitiveness, and ensure sustainable growth.

Adopting a structured framework for evaluating AI projects, leveraging global and regional benchmarks, and tailoring strategies to local market realities enables IT leaders to maximize the value of every investment. The journey may begin with small but measurable initiatives; what truly matters is iterating, learning, and improving consistently while celebrating data-driven progress.

If your organization is ready to turn AI’s potential into measurable results within ITSM, now is the ideal time to explore specialized solutions and rely on regional experts. The next chapter of your IT strategy can be built on smart decisions, tangible returns, and a responsible approach to artificial intelligence.